August 16, 2017 DRAFT Village Council Minutes

The August 2017 Draft Minutes have not been received by Bear Lake News. The following have been supplied to us by a concerned citizen. {a pdf of the Minutes was received 8/31]


Village of Bear Lake Council

REGULAR MEETING August 16, 2017 Bear Lake Village Hall Unapproved Minutes

The regular meeting of the Bear Lake Vii/age Council was called to order by President Jeff Bair at 7 p.m. at the Village Hall. Pledge of Allegiance was said.

Present: President: Jeff Bair Council: Peggy Bass, Marla Evans, Joanne Schroeder, Ron Ronning and Greg McPherson Treasurer: Sally King, Clerk: Cindi McPherson Staff: Jared Bair and Larry Gibson Absent: Jackie Johnson

Guests: Six (6) guests signed in

Motion to Adopt the Agenda as presented with addition by Ronning and seconded by McPherson,

motion carried. Aye: Bass, Evans, G. McPherson, Ronning, Schroeder, Bair Nay: none Absent: Johnson

Public Comment on:

• None

Correspondence: Read by clerk:

• None

REPORTS: Approval July 19, 2017 Regular Meeting:

• Motion to approve minutes from July 19, 2017 Regular Meeting by Bass, seconded by Ronning. Motion Carried.

Aye: Bass, Evans, McPherson, Ronning, Bair Nay: None Abstain: Schroeder Absent: Johnson

Maintenance Report: Reviewed by President Bair. Written report on file with August 2017 minutes

Treasurer’s Report: Reviewed by King. Written report on file in the August 2017 minutes binder. King stated property taxes are coming in. Also receiving payments for 3rd quarter water bills. No questions from the council.

General checking/savings total 38,981.64
checking only 29,367.52
Money Market Account 10,067.24
checking/savings total 23,544.68
Park CD#2 33,065.98
Major Street
checking/savings total 33,985.52 Minor Street checking/savings total 16,513.18 Equipment Fund checking/savings total 3,162.68 Honor Bank CD 26,019.74

Motion to accept the Treasurer’s Report by Ronning seconded by McPherson, motion carried. Aye: Bass, Evans, Johnson, McPherson, Ronning, Schroeder, Bair Nay: none Absent: Johnson

Motion to transfer June’s Equipment Rental $1,258.44 from General Fund back to Park Fund by Ronning, seconded by Evans. Motion Carried. Aye: Bass, Evans, Johnson, McPherson, Ronning, Schroeder, Bair Nay: none Absent: Johnson

o Amendments to Budget 2017-2018

• A motion was made to approve amendments as listed below to the 2017 2018 budget by McPherson, seconded by Bass. Motion carried. Aye: Bass, Evans, Johnson, McPherson Ronning, Bair Nays: None Absent: Schroeder

Increase Water Equipment Rental to $2,500

Increase Park Salary/Wages to $13K

Increase Park Fee Revenue to $40k

• Increase Major Tree Removal $2,400, from MML Insurance Bills to be paid presented by Clerk. List on file in August 2017 minutes folder. Motion to pay the bills by Ronning, seconded by Evans. Motion carried.

Aye: Bass, Evans, Johnson, McPherson, Ronning, Schroeder, Bair Nay: none Absent: Johnson

• Reimbursements to the General Fund were read by President Bair.

o Wages to General Fund: $3,502.85

o Equipment Rental to General Fund: $521.13

Committee Chair Reports:

Park: President Bair reported campsite reservation are over $40K for the calendar year. McPherson and Park committee will review cancellation fees and campsite fees for 2018. Park committee will discuss & present recommendation at September meeting.

Streets, Trees, Signs, Ughts, Sidewalks: President Bair recommended this committee meet to discuss repaving Cody/Wise Street during water project trepaving & secure bids bids before water project begins.

Water: Ken Micek gave an update on water/well project; everything required is done. Waiting on our attorney Hryns to finish some paper work, no response from him. Micek suggested we ask our current attorney to finish this part. Project has been delayed due to this situation.

Motion was made by McPherson, this week, Friday (8/18/17) will be the deadline for attorney Hryns response on water project. President Bair to follow up with Hryns. If no response, clerk will contact village attorney to begin water project work. President Bair asked the treasurer to look into Flamingo Freeze water hook-up at their current building. Are they paying a water bill or using Correct Compressions water?

Buildings, Grounds & Equipment:

Motion made by McPherson to authorize Wolverine Power to do maintenance on wells -signed one (1) year contract ($490). President Bair stated a generator & shop vac were purchased for well house. Reimbursement to Bair for purchase is in the “Bills to be Paid”. President Bair reported the museum roof by the bathroom is still leaking. Building committee will meet to discuss options.

Blight/CABA: CABA: Manistee County Treasurer, Russ Pomeroy, is preparing a grant application to the Tribal Grant Revenue Sharing (LRBOCl)for help with taking down the Variety Building. Tribel Revenue sharing money available is $110K. Pomeroy is requesting letters of support from businesses, organizations and individuals, would like 100, deadline is 8/20/17. The Revenue Sharing money is to be used for “Safety” projects.

BLIGHT: Gibson report on file in August 2017 minutes folder.

Planning Commission: Chairperson Barb Farfsing gave a report on Planning Commissions July meeting. Report on file in August’s minute folder.

Manistee County Trail Committee Report: McPherson informed us there was no meeting.

Bear Lake Improvement Board: McPherson gave a report, on file in August 2017 minutes file.

Two Lakes Sewer Collaborative: McPherson reported they have not met yet.

Ad Hoc -Policy, Resolution & Ordinance Committee No report Looking for a volunteer student to help out. Working with Jeff Harthun for a possible student.


• Appointment of elected positions Clerk McPherson stated she had not yet heard back from the village attorneys at this time.


• Laura Heintzelman from Manistee County Community Foundation (MCCF) spoke on the on the Blight Fund and preserving the charitable intent for this fund. She has revised the agreement between MCCF, Village of Bear Lake & CABA. And asked the council to make a motion to accept the new agreement. Motion was made by McPherson to accept the newly revised agreement with MCCF & CABA, seconded by Bass. Motion carried.

Aye: Bass, Evans, Johnson, McPherson, Ronning, Schroeder, Bair Nay: none Absent: Johnson

• Rob Carson & Tamara Buskwinka presented on US-31 Corridor Project. They would like support from the council on this project. Motion was made by Ronning to support the US-31 Corridor plan presented by Carson & Bushwinka. Seconded by McPherson. Motion Carried.

Aye: Bass, Evans, Johnson, McPherson, Ronning, Schroeder, Bair Nay: none Absent: Johnson

President Bair spoke on Mead & Hunt’s contract for sampling and testing of Village water good through August 2017. He recommends not extending their contract. Suggests hiring Ben Heymes for this sampling & testing. Heymes would be hired by the village at a possible rate of $25 per hour~ testing would be approx 4 hours week. He currently does this for the village of Mesick. Cross Connection contract is still good through 2019.

Motion by McPherson to not renew the contract with Mead & Hunt for sampling & testing and look for another provider. Seconded by Bass. Motion carried. Aye: Bass, Evans, Johnson, McPherson, Ronning, Schroeder, Bair Nay: none Absent: Johnson

• Motion by Bass to support for proceeding of winter banners, seconded by McPherson.

Motion carried. Aye: Bass, Evans, Johnson, McPherson, Ronning, Schroeder, Bair Nay: none Absent: Johnson

• Discussion on employee, Jared Bairs health insurance payment. The village can no longer make his payment for him according to the Affordable Care Act. Motion was made by McPherson to have the clerk & treasurer look for a way to pay for Jared’s insurance. Seconded by Ronning. Motion carried.

Aye: Bass, Evans, Johnson, McPherson, Ronning, Schroeder, Bair Nay: . none Absent: Johnson

Barb Farfsing spoke on holiday banners in the village. Motion by Ronning for the village to purchase a holiday banner. Seconded by Evans. Motion carried.

Aye: Bass, Evans, Johnson, McPherson, Ronning, Schroeder, Bair Nay: none Absent: Johnson

Motion by Bass to amend the budget to allow for the purchase of the holiday banner. Move $150 from communications to seasonal in the General Fund to allow for the purchase. Seconded by Ronning. Motion carried.

Aye : Bass, Evans, Johnson, McPherson, Ronning, Schroeder, Bair .Nay: none Absent: Johnson

Follow up on item from July monthly meeting.

o Clerk McPherson followed up on FOIA Itemization charge. Because of the statuette the charges on the time frame it takes to look up information on a FOIA request cannot be changed.


• None


Pauline Jacquish spoke on the upcoming 125 anniversary year of Bear Lake celebration. She would like to see music on the deck area for the summer of 2018. And wanted the support of the council. Yes, support by the council. Clarification that the deck is safe to hold lots of people.

Jacquish reported on the Manistee County Auction; White 2 story building in back of Variety Store was sold for $2K, for a kids ministry. Pioneer Press building/house -no bids.

Jacquish reported that AES is in reorganization. City of Manistee withdrew financial support of $40K. Manistee County will continue with $90K support. The village should

send in 5 things we want AES to continue to support and what works for us and what does not, by middle of next week

Jacquish reported that 500 individuals came into the museum over Bear Lake Days.

Barb Farfsing would like to see a history plaque “Proud of our Past” at the kayak/canoe launch site or something along that line for the celebration.


Community Garage Sales, Saturday August 19, 2017

Hazardous Waste Collection tor Manistee County, Saturday August l9

• Thursday evening, dinner for the Food Pantry Meeting adjourned at 9:07p.m.

Respectfully Submitted, Cindi McPherson, Clerk


WAGES July 2017

Major Street AMOUNT $191.48

Minor Street AMOUNT $191.48

Park Fund AMOUNT  $2,560.89

Water Fund AMOUNT  $559.00 

Total transfer to General Fund AMOUNT S3,502.85


Major Street $165.32

Minor Street $165.32

Water Fund $190.49

Total transfer to Equipment Fund  $521.13

Bills To Be Paid:

Payee Young, Graham, Wendling PC $400.00
Account # 101-265-801 Notes June and August phone retainer

Jackpine Internet $50.00
Account # 101-265-910 changes to web site

Mark Thompson Tree & Stump $191.25
Account # 101-000-951 brush pickup

TOTAL $641.25


Alliance for Economic Success $207.37
Account # 591-000-890 Vil portion to publish Articles of Inc.

Reimburse Jeff Bair $343.43 Genorator & shop vac

King & MacGregor Environmental $691.20
Account #591-558-801 Bat habitat evaluation

Mead & Hunt $ 2,182.80
Account #591-000-801 June and July 2017

Jackpine Business Center $52.11
Account #591-558-727 widow envelopes

TOTAL $3,476.91


Young, Graham, Wendling, PC  $64.00
Account #531-000-970  
Resolution to purchase “Oddfellowsprop

Staples Credit Plan $155.84
Account #531-000-740  cardstock & soap dispenser

BL Ace Hardware $163.02
Account #531-000-775  maintenance supplies

BP $50.83
Account #531-000-775  fuel

TOTAL 433.69


BP $50.82
Account #202-265-776  fuel

Mark Thompson Tree & Stump $600.00
Account #202-200-951  1/2 tree removal 7983 Lake Street

Auto-Wares Group $11.48
Account #202-463-782  oil for sander

TOTAL $662.30


BP $50.82
Account #203-265-776  fuel

Auto-Wares Group $11.47

Account #203-463-782  fuel

TOTAL $62.29


Errors and Omissions 2

A past subscriber was a Certified Public accountant who was previously employed by the State of Michigan Department of Treasury.

In prior Audits the Village has been advised in the strongest possible terms to maintain a separation of duties and financial access.
The Clerk keeps the books and accounts. The Treasurer receives, accounts for and disperses approved funds. Each maintains separate spreadsheets which should match independently. See Page 18 of the attached Michigan Municipal League Handbook for Village Officials
Bank Reconciliation
All bank accounts must be reconciled to the local unit accounting records monthly. The Clerk’s records must agree with or reconcile to the Treasurer’s and the bank’s records. A reconciliation sheet should be prepared in duplicate for each month with one copy for the Clerk and one copy for the Treasurer. Canceled checks are to be filed with the bank statement to which they apply.
In addition – we note in the June meeting an authorization for Trustee Schroeder to be a signatory on checks? This is not permitted under both the Uniform Accounting Procedures and the General Law Village Act :
● Dual signatures are required for all checking accounts (except the separate tax collection checking account). The dual signatures MUST be the clerk (or deputy clerk) and the treasurer (or deputy treasurer).
Current FY To Date spreadsheets should have been presented for both the Budget meeting and to approve amendments at all Council meetings.
The financial advisor compares the two reports as being the difference in knowing only what is in a current checking account without taking into account a) how long those funds must cover expenses (in a unit of government this is from one tax receipt year to the next) and b) how much is actually ‘unencumbered’ i.e how much has been committed as a future debit.
In response to a request for a current financial report the following was received.

Errors and Omissions 1

In response to comments and questions concerning the recording of local government meetings our advisor published this previous post.

Upon reviewing the July Village Council Draft Minutes – published here – subscribers have noted the following questions when comparing the Draft Minutes to the audio recording.

[It should be noted that the audio quality of the new Village telephone conference line is poor. We have offered to provide a noise cancelling microphone as it appears the conference line is being provided via a wireless device.]

Following the May Council meeting, in time for this matter to be corrected in June, the Clerk was alerted that the Motion to approve the newly revised agreement concerning the MCCF Blight Elimination Fund was not included.

“A Subscriber has noted the DRAFT Minutes do not contain the discussion and Motion (by Johnson. Second by McPherson) to accept the amended CABA Blight Elimination Fund agreement?”

By also approving the June Minutes in July, without correcting that omission, there is no official authorization to sign and enter into an amended agreement to oversee the Blight Elimination, not CABA, Fund with the Manistee County Community Foundation.



The Village of Bear Lake Village Council will be holding a public hearing to approve the budget for 2017-18 fiscal year on June 21, 2017 at 7pm at the Bear LakeVillage Hall, 12376 Virginia Street. The regular monthly council meeting will immediately follow.
A copy of the proposed budget is available for public inspection at the Village of Bear Lake office, 12376 Virginia Street during regular business hours; Monday
 – Friday, 1pm -3pm.
Persons with disabilities needing accommodations for effective participation in the public hearing/public meeting should contact the Bear Lake Village Clerk at 231.970.2066 or at the above address one week in advance to request mobility, visual, hearing, or other assistance.
 Cindi McPherson, Clerk Village of Bear Lake
{Current Approved FY 2017-18 Budget – 2017-18 Budget Worksheets ]

Clarification of suspicious activity

Recently Village subscribers have noted a slow moving vehicle pausing in front of vacant homes. A subscriber noted that a Village Council Trustee was thought to have been recognized. On enquiry of the Village Clerk the following was received:

“May 24: Larry Gibson, Blight Enforcement Officer & Trustee Greg McPherson, Chair for the Blight Committee, were doing a routine blight check in the Village of Bear Lake.”


Village of Bear Lake – April 19, 2017 meeting documents

It should be noted that these were received May 24, 2017.

A prior request citing Michigan Open Meetings Act, Village of Bear Lake Title VI Non Discrimination Policy and a 6 month Freedom of Information request has asked for meeting documents be made available prior to each meeting to allow equitable access for those unable to attend due to age, infirmity or disability.

A renewal 6 month request will be posted for June – November 2017 – again requesting documents be Section 508 compliant, text readable format.

Here is a the text readable Treasurer Report PDF as presented to the April Council Meeting.

Treasurer’s Report 3-31-17 click here to open

March 31, 2017 Statement Balances






Ending Balance



Equipment 2700 checking





8793 savings






81113080 Honor Bank CD (former CD#1)






Minor Street 2727 checking





8637 savings






Major Street 2719 checking





8645 savings






Park 2735 checking





8769 savings






0862 CD#2






Water 2743 checking






0875 Money Market Account






General 2689 checking





8629 savings






No Clerk’s Finance Reports were received for the March or April Meetings.

Village of Bear Lake Blight Enforcement Report April 19, 2017

2017-04-19 Blight Report

  • 7667 Stuart St.
    • Talked to new owner. Frost law regulations lifted on 4-10, will be bringing in equipment to bulldoze and remove debris within a couple of weeks.
    • Plans to start construction of his garage as soon as the lot is cleard.
  • 12238 Virginia St.
    • No reply from owner to my last email.  Property believed to have gone for back taxes on March 31st.
  • 12273 Lynn St.
    • No new information at this time.
  • 12252 Maple St.
    • Inspected & photograph property.  Initial contact letter sent.
  • Blight Enforcement Tickets.
    • Received information from our attorney’s office.  Have contacted a company for information and price quote on tickets to be used when issuing a violation.

Respectfully submitted by,

Larry J. Gibson

Blight Enforcement Officer

Reports April 2017 Village councle report

April 2017 Village Council meeting maintenance report


  • Graded the road
  • Got more road gravel for the park drive so we can fill in potholes and low spots
  • Raked and leaf blew the entire park
  • All the fire rings are on every campsite
  • Most of the picnic tables are out on the campsites only have a few more lots to put them out on, have to repair the rest before they get out out
  • Park bathrooms are open
  • Had to repair a water main that runs the parks water


  • Tan work truck is in the shop getting serviced and the red truck is going in once we get the other truck back
  • Got new push mower and weedwacker, the weedwacker is a combi system so it can have different attachments run off of it, we also got a edger for it and a rubber brush. The rubber brush helps clean out sand and rocks from where I plowed at on the side of the road


  • Daily well checks
  • Took down the flags on the fire hydrants
  • Monthly water paperwork and water testing done
  • Weekly well checks with Ben (Our licensed operator at this time)
  • Couple water turn ons


  • Picked up sand piles around town
  • Put up a new flag at the beach across from Blarney Castle
  • Planning on getting the sander out of the dump truck here soon
  • Graded the drive at the sand building and also at the well houses
  • Cleaned up the sidewalk in front of where the fire was the other day
  • Rotated and moved some of the compost pile
  • Got the plow off the front of the tan work truck
  • Got the shop cleaned out and swept all the sand out of them that the dump truck left behind
  • Went around town and cleaned up the shoulder of the road from where I tore up during the winter time

Report to Bear Lake Village Council  April 19, 2017 Planning Commission Organizational Meeting April 18, 2017 @ 2:00 p.m.

Members of Planning Commission:

Bill Beaver

Barb Farfsing

Cindi McPherson

Myrna Walter

Election of Officers took place:

Chairperson – Barb Farfsing

Vice Chairperson – Bill Beaver

Secretary – Cindi McPherson

Dates for future Planning Commission meetings will be the 2nd Tuesday of each month May through October beginning at 6 p.m. to be held at the Village Hall.

New members were brought up to date on what involves being on the Planning Commission.

Discussion on Zoning

Respectfully Submitted by Barb Farfsing

VILLAGE OF BEAR LAKE  RESOLUTION NO. 5 OF 2017 – click here to view a text readable version Res authorizing water rates 03-24-17

Resolution to Adjust Water Rates per Ordinance No. 2001-1

Pursuant to Section 13 of the Ordinance

At a regular meeting of the Village Council of Bear Lake held in the Village Hall located at 12376 Virginia Street, Bear Lake, Michigan, 49614 on April 19, 2017 at 7 p.m.

PRESENT: Bair, Bass, Evans, Johnson, McPherson, Ronning, Schroeder


The following resolution was made by McPherson and seconded by Johnson, to-wit:

WHEREAS, Waterworks Ordinance 2001-1, Section 13, allows the Village Council to establish and change water rates from time to time by the Village Council, and

WHEREAS, it is necessary to make an adjustment to the rates in order to meet USDA requirements, and

WHEREAS, the Village Council had passed a motion at their regular meeting on February 15, 2017 to adjust those rates, but was requested by the USDA to have the adjustment contained in a separate resolution form.

NOW THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED THAT: the Village Council hereby adjusts the water rates to increase in April, 2017 making all users as of April, 2017 pay One Hundred Twenty and 00/100 ($120.00) Dollars per REU per quarter, and for such rates to increase again beginning in October, 2017 to One Hundred Thirty-Five and 00/100 ($135.00) Dollars per REU per quarter to meet USDA requirements.

YES: 7

NO: 0


By: Jeffery Bair

Its: Village President

The following was received but is not signed or dated- Village of Bear Lake Resolution to ARTICLES OF INCORPORATION 03 14 17

The text can be read here.


RESOLUTION NO. ___________


The resolution was offered by _______________________________________ and supported by ________________________________________________________.

WHEREAS, the Village Council was presented with Articles of Incorporation of the Three Lake Collaborative Sewer Authority authorized by Act 233 of 1955 as amended, MCL 124.281 et seq, and

WHEREAS, the Village of Bear Lake can be a member and constituent municipality of the Three Lake Collaborative Sewer Authority by approving and adopting the Articles of Incorporation, and

WHEREAS, the five municipalities considering adoption of the Articles of Incorporation are Onekama Township, Pleasanton Township, Arcadia Township, Bear Lake Township, and the Village of Bear Lake, and

WHEREAS, the stated purpose of the Three Lake Collaborative Sewer Authority is to plan, design, engineer, finance, construct, and operate a public sewage disposal system serving sewage districts within the constituent municipalities of Onekama Township, Pleasanton Township, Arcadia Township, Bear Lake Township, and the Village of Bear Lake, and transporting the collected wastewater for treatment to the facilities of the Little River Band of Ottawa Indians, an Indian Tribe as defined in MCL 124.281(c) with which the Authority can contract for wastewater treatment, and

WHEREAS, the Village Council is prepared to approve and adopt the Articles of Incorporation,

NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Village Council approves and hereby adopts the Articles of Incorporation of the Three Lake Collaborative Sewer Authority as presented at this meeting and authorizes and directs the Village President and the Village Clerk to endorse and sign the Articles of Incorporation.

BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the Village Council appoints _______________________ as the Village representative to serve on the Three Lake Collaborative Sewer Authority Board.

YEAS: ___________________

NAYS: ___________________

The Village President declared the Resolution _________________________________________, on the __________ day of __________________________, 2017.

I hereby certify the foregoing Resolution was adopted by the Village Council at a meeting held on _______________________________________, 2017.


Cindi McPherson, Village Clerk

Regulating Medical Marijuana Facilities: A Workshop for Local Government

Michigan State University Extension and the Land Policy Institute recently collaborated to deliver training to more than 800 people on the Medical Marihuana Facilities Licensing Act passed in 2016. The training targeted local units of government to explain their options under the new laws.
In addition to conducting a webinar training, the “Regulating Medical Marijuana Facilities: A Workshop for Local Government” was conducted at various locations around the state during February and March 2017.
An MSU Extension web page is now available that houses useful information related to the Licensing Act, including resources from the training, such as impacts and effects, sample ordinances, fact sheets, Q&A’s and more. Learn more at: Medical Marihuana Facilities Licensing Act.
Photo courtesy of MSU Extension.

April 19, 2017 Village Council DRAFT Minutes

To comply with Section 508 – here is a text readable version of the PDF received – Drafted Minutes April 19, 2017

Village of Bear Lake Council REGULAR MEETING

April 19, 2017 Bear Lake Village Hall

Unapproved Minutes

The regular meeting of the Bear Lake Village Council was called to order by President Jeff Bair at 7:00 p.m. at the Village Hall. Pledge of Allegiance was said.

Present: President: Jeff Bair Council: Peggy Bass, Jackie Johnson, Marla Evans, Joanne Schroeder, Ron Ronning and Greg McPherson
Treasurer: Sally King, Clerk: Cindi McPherson Staff: Larry Gibson and Jared Bair

Absent: none

Guests: Nineteen (19) guests signed in

Motion to Adopt the Agenda as presented and with additions by McPherson and seconded by Ronning, motion carried.
Aye: Bass, Evans, Johnson, G. McPherson, Ronning, Schroeder, Bair
Nay: none


  • After Adoption of Agenda – update on burned building
    • Old Business:
      o Re-accept the Articles of Incorporation, sewer – Clerk McPherson
      o DeRidder sewer update – Bass
    • New Business
      o Attorney Quinn not present, Ben Guerra to present
    • o Signage – Bass

Update on Odd Fellows burned building – Jeff Bair

  • Building is Manistee County owned and insured at this time due to back taxes. The county will make the site safe after removal of burned building material. Unsure of future of site at this time.

Public Comment on:

  • “No Parking” signs at Smith & Main Streets – Bair stated it is going up.
  • Maple trees need to come down on Lynn Street – Bair stated, Thompson tree company will be checking this out and other trees around town.
  • Medical Marijuana dispenser in Bear Lake downtown and distribution hubs. He is opposed to any within the village/township of Bear Lake.
    o Additional guest commented that Bear Lake Township is writing an ordinance on Medical Marijuana.
  • Thank you for the use of the Village Hall during the fire for CERT to use, very helpful.

Correspondence: Read by clerk:

  • Letter from Manistee, Mason, Oceana Household Hazardous Waste Committee.
  • Email from Dendra Best, survey for Betsie River Access Site Assessment.


Approval March 15, 2017 minutes:

  • Motion to approve minutes from March 15, 2017 Regular Meeting with addition by Ronning, seconded by McPherson. Motion Carried.
    Aye: Bass, Evans, Johnson, McPherson, Ronning, Schroeder, Bair
    Nay: None
    Absent: None
  • Maintenance Report: Read by Jared Bair. Report on file with April 2017 minutes [NOTE: a copy has no thus far been received by Bear Lake News]
  • Treasurer’s Report: read by King. Report on file in the 2017 minutes binder.

    March Treasurer’s Report

    March 31, 2017 Statement Balance:
    Equipment Fund checking/savings total 3,270.67
    Honor Bank CD 26,009.55
    Minor Street checking/savings total 15,254.39
    Major Street checking/savings total 29,544.76
    Park checking/savings total 24,437.54
    Park CD#2 32,918.90
    Water checking only 3,128.82
    Money Market Account 10,053.97
    General checking/savings total 52,309.28

Motion to accept Treasurer’s by Ronning seconded by Bass, motion carried.
Aye: Bass, Evans, Johnson, McPherson, Ronning, Schroeder, Bair
Nay: none

  • Bills to be paid were read by Clerk.

Motion to pay the bills by McPherson, seconded by Schroeder. Motion carried.
Aye: Bass, Evans, Johnson, McPherson, Ronning, Schroeder, Bair
Nay: none

  • Reimbursements to the General Fund were read by President Bair. Total to General Fund: $3,019.90
  • Committee Chair Reports:

Park: Discussion on adding increasing pump out prices for campers. Currently $16

Motion to increase campers at Hopkins Park pump out service to $20 regular, $25 emergency by McPherson, seconded by Ronning. Motion carried.
Aye: Bass, Evans, Johnson, McPherson, Ronning, Schroeder, Bair
Nay: none

Discussion on lot price increase and surcharge to campers tabled until fall 2017.

Loss of two camp sites due to fire until clean-up is complete.

Trees: McPherson’s asked to plant a tree on village right of way between sidewalk & street, Smith & Main Streets.

Streets: Pot hole patch will begin the end of April. Some streets will be repaired during the water project.

Water: Bair commented, our water attorney is a little slow at getting needed paperwork for the water project.

Equipment: Bair reported he attended a Revenue Sharing (Little River Band) meeting in Manistee. Over $400K in grant money was submitted and $100+K in grant money will be given out. Money for dump truck & swim safety equipment were submitted for funding. USDA grant money for dump truck is open. 40/60 match.

Sidewalk: No report

Blight/CABA: Gibson gave a verbal report. Report on file in April’s minute folder. Gibson report on citation booklets and cost. He will order 2 booklets.

Village of Bear Lake Blight Enforcement Report April 19, 2017

  • 7667 Stuart St.
    • Talked to new owner. Frost law regulations lifted on 4-10, will be bringing in equipment to bulldoze and remove debris within a couple of weeks.
    • Plans to start construction of his garage as soon as the lot is cleard.
  • 12238 Virginia St.
    • No reply from owner to my last email.  Property believed to have gone for back taxes on March 31st.
  • 12273 Lynn St.
    • No new information at this time.
  • 12252 Maple St.
    • Inspected & photograph property.  Initial contact letter sent.
  • Blight Enforcement Tickets.
    • Received information from our attorney’s office.  Have contacted a company for information and price quote on tickets to be used when issuing a violation.

Respectfully submitted by, Larry J. Gibson
Blight Enforcement Officer

Bair reported he would like to start interview process for a Blight Hearing Officer. Qualifications; Experience in building trades and knowledge of building codes.

Planning Commission: Chairperson Barb Farfsing gave a report on Planning Commissions organizational meeting on April 18 at 2pm. Report on file in April’s minute’s folder. One additional member is needed. Must be a village resident who is registered to vote.

Village of Bear Lake Planning Commission
Organizational Meeting April 18, 2017

Village Hall
Unapproved Minutes

Organizational meeting called to order at 2:08pm by Village Council President Jeff Bair

Pledge of Allegiance was said by all.

Roll Call: Barb Farfsing, Cindi McPherson, Myrna Walter and Bill Beaver

Recognition of visitors: None

Reviewed By-Laws

Election of officers

Chairperson – Barb Farfsing

Vicechair – Bill Beaver

Secretary – Cindi McPherson

Motion was made by Beaver to accept the slate of officers for 2017, seconded by Farfsing. Motion carried

Yays – 4

Nays – 0

Set year meeting dates and time:

May 9, June 13, July 11, August 8, September 12 and October 10, 2017

Meeting time is 6pm. Meeting place will be the Village Hall.

Public Comments: None

Correspondence: None

Commissioners comments: Discussion on zoning

Next meeting; May 9, 2017 at Bear Lake Village Hall @ 6pm

Adjourned at 3:23pm

Respectfully submitted by Cindi McPherson

Manistee County Trail Committee Report: Clerk McPherson read emails from volunteer representative Dendra Best. Reports are on file in April minute’s folder. There was no meeting in April.

Ad Hoc – Policy, Resolution & Ordinance Committee – No report


  • Clerk McPherson asked council if they would prefer to re-accept a clean copy (without correction marks) of the Articles of Incorporation for the Sewer Projects. Council members agreed it was not necessary as long as there were no changes; there were not.
  • DeRidder Sewer update – Council member Bass wanted an update on where the DeRidder’s are with their sewer project. No update was available. [NOTE: completed under the jurisdiction of District #10 DHD Manistee County]


  • Motion to adopt a Resolution adopting the Articles of Incorporation of the Three Lakes Collaborative Sewer Authority by Ronning, seconded by Johnson. Motion carried.
    Aye: Bass, Evans, Johnson, McPherson, Ronning, Schroeder, Bair
    Nay: None [Note a copy has been requested]
  • Motion to appoint Jeff Bair as Sewer Representative per Sewer Resolution by Johnson, seconded by McPherson. Motion carried.
    Aye: Bass, Evans, Johnson, McPherson, Ronning, Schroeder, Bair
    Nay: None
  • Motion to accept the Resolution to Adjust Water Rates per Ordinance No. 2001-1 requested by the USDA by McPherson, seconded by Johnson. Motion carried. [Note a copy has been requested ]
    Aye: Bass, Evans, Johnson, McPherson, Ronning, Schroeder, Bair
    Nay: None
  • Motion to purchase a Welcome to Bear Lake banner to be hung on the Village Hall by Ronning, seconded by Evans. Motion carried.
    Aye: Bass, Evans, Johnson, McPherson, Ronning, Schroeder, Bair
    Nay: None
    Printed at the bottom of the banner “Village Office”.
    Bass also commented on interior signage for offices. Ideas of interior signage are being reviewed.
  • Ben Guerra & Chris Hardesty spoke on Medical Marijuana regarding dispensary/regulations on growing & selling marijuana in the village of Bear Lake. The Planning Commission will discuss. Concerns shared and discussion was held.


  • Pauline Jaquish, Manistee County Commissioner, gave a verbal update on Leckrone properties acquired in tax foreclosure and the burned down building (Odd Fellows Hall) is currently owned by Manistee County. The Odd Fellows Hall building was insurance by the county and the county will clean up the building site when it is released by the Fire Marshall.
  • Variety Store – is county owned and the county is getting bids on the building to demolish and remove. Bear Lake community may want to do a community fundraising project for funding.

    • Community Dinner this Thursday 5pm -7pm
    • Lake Improvement Board Meeting April 20 at 7pm at Bear Lake Township Hall
    • Village of Bear Lake Community Clean-Up day, June 24, 9am – 1pm
    • Bear Lake Promoters After Hour Event will take place on May 18, 2017 at 5-7pm at Bear Lake Hardware Design Center. Speakers will be landscape architects from Beckett & Raeder discussing the US 31 Corridor Plan.

Meeting adjourned at 8:40p.m.

Respectfully Submitted,

Cindi McPherson, Clerk



Major Street 3/01/2017 – 3/31/2017 $149.50

Minor Street 3/01/2017 – 3/31/2017 $162.50

Park Fund 3/01/2017 – 3/31/2017 $609.50

Water Fund 3/01/2017 – 3/31/2017 $390.00


Major Street $462.15

Minor Street $562.71

Park Fund $239.25

Water Fund $444.29

Bills To Be Paid

Date: April 19, 2017

Name | Amount|  Fund|  Account Notes

Jack Pine 25.00 Water Newsletter

50.97 General Toner

49.00 General Bus cards Blight

Mead & Hunt 1,141.10 Water Water test/sampling

Bittner/Jennings Attorney 61.43 Water Call w/ Ken

156.98 General FOIA

Auto Wares Group/ Auto 25.00 Major

Bear Lake Ace Hardware 110.93 Park Paint & supplies

Blarney Castle 1,063.20 Park Maint. Buildin

Young, Graham & Wendling 77.50 Water Water Rate Resol.

449.50 Park Joint Part kayak/canoe

325.50 General Sewer Authority

Staples 135.98 General office supplies

2003 Sewer Project – review of plans and decisions

For a review of decisions made by the Village of Bear Lake which culminated in the decision to withdraw due to cost – see Archived Minutes from 2000, 2001,  2002, 2003 and 2004.

To review the Preliminary Engineering Report – click here




“The total estimated project cost which the Bear Lake-Pleasanton Area Utilities Authority will be financing is $10.75 million. This is detailed in Table 19 and consists of the cost for collection, transmission, treatment and land cost associated with treatment.

4. Debt Retirement. Table 19 contains the estimated project cost of $10,750,000 for wastewater collection, transmission and treatment for facilities constructed by the Bear Lake- Pleasanton Area Utilities Authority. This estimated cost does not include a buy-in cost with the Village of Onekama, which will need to be negotiated between the Authority, the Village of Bear Lake and Rural Development.

An estimated payment schedule has been developed based upon a 40-year loan and an assumed interest rate of 4.5%. Under Rural Development guidelines, the area qualifies as an area of poverty with respect to median family income. Using the above project cost of $10. 75 million, the average monthly payment for debt retirement is $70.00 per month. This is based upon using 695 REUs to pay for the estimated $584,000 per year debt payment. This combined with the annual operation and maintenance monthly average payment of $10.5 per month produces a monthly average payment of $80.50 for debt retirement and operation and maintenance.”

Village of Bear Lake – Utility Authority November 3, 2003

As a result of the correspondence received recently by the BLP Utility Authority from USDA RD; the discussions with the Village Attorney; the consensus of the last Utility Authority Board meeting; and the comments made and actions taken at the October 2003 Bear Lake Township Meeting there are a number of questions and issues Council needs to come to a consensus on.

To recap:

June 2000: The Village pledged to pay $5000 as 1/3 cost of the Sewer Feasibility Study. At that time only a municipal sewer system was proposed although other treatment options were to be considered.

March 2001: Feasibility Study published.

April 2, 2001: The Feasibility Board showed a Balance on account of $2249.33

June 16 2001: Public Meeting.

On the basis of the Feasibility Study a figure of $37,5000 was proposed to fund a “Preliminary Engineering Study” which was supposed to consider a wider range of options and give a more in depth review of the demographics and volume of system that would be needed.

The only written request for funds was received in August, 2001 requesting 1/3 of $37,500 for funding the engineering study.

November 2001: Village approved payment of $2,5000.00

The Feasibility Board was formed under Urban Cooperation Act of 1967, as contained in MCL 124.501, et seq. which would have allowed the Board to apply for storm water control funding in addition to water systems and sanitary collection and treatment.

In April of 2002 that agreement was extended for another 12 months forming the BLPL Sewer Board. (But the agreement only authorized a payment of $5000 per entity, both in the original and in the extension.)

July 13, 2002 the Village Paid $5000.00

In 2002 the 2 Townships began negotiations to change the scope of the project to send treatment and collection to the Village of Onekama rather than build our own treatment facility. USDA RD indicated that might increase the likelihood of funding.

April 14, 2003: The Village paid $5000 to complete our requested funds,$12,500.00.

Under pressure from the 2 Townships the Village agreed to sign the new agreement to form the Bear Lake Pleasanton Area Utilities Authority – not signing would have effectively removed the Village from further participation in sewer/sanitation planning.

The new agreement was drafted under the MUNICIPAL SEWAGE AND WATER SUPPLY SYSTEMS Act 233 of 1955 which specifically designates funding and excludes funding for storm water control.

Glen Moore and Dendra Best were appointed to be the Village Board members with Carol Urbanus as our alternate. (Neither of the Townships have appointed an alternate member to this point.)

Following the first meeting of the BLPAUA a report was sent to Council relaying your representatives concerns and areas where there were points that needed clarification. (See the Village web site: reports are attached to the Minutes.)

Chief among them was the question of whether there were outstanding bills from the previous Board – we were told there were none.

Secondly was the issue of what stage the BLPAUA application process at to USDA RD was – we were concerned that no contract be signed or approved until we had received the Preliminary Engineering Report from Prein Newhoff and had had time to consider the projects potential impact on the community.

A draft of the Preliminary Report was received in April and Council had serious concerns that it seemed to merely repeat the information contained in the Feasibility Study with the same errors in listing the demographics plus financial errors in listing the newly increased costs and scope of rerouting the collection and treatment to the Village of Onekama.

No other options were presented for consideration in this Report. We also had serious concerns about a) the assumptions made for ‘zero growth’ ; and b) the impact on groundwater in light of our delineated Wellhead Protection area. The proposed irrigation field comes within 6/10 of a mile of the wellhead catchment and there is insufficient data to satisfy us this will not present a future pollution source.

The Final format of the Preliminary Report was received within the week without any of the requested changes being made – but a response from Prein NEwhof indicated our points of concern would be sent on to USDA RD.

The Final Report included an extension of the service area south on US31, which was added after the fact.

The Village of Onekama now has an official ‘option to purchase’ the Bear Lake Township Supervisor’s property, on Linderman and 11 Mile Road, on which they intend to construct their, and potentially our, irrigation.

At several meetings we have asked on the status of the ‘application’ – has one been made or not? It appears from the response from USDA RD that the preliminary application was sent in on May 7. The BLPAUA met on May 21 and did not approve that action until that time. We believed we were seeking a provisional opinion only.

Council requested our Attorney review the 2 contracts being presented for approval – presented as being a precursor to any application. On his advice we requested additional language be included in both the contract for legal and engineering services. We also asked that no contract be awarded without a formal bidding process. Attorney Wilson asked for and was awarded the contract for legal services. It was our understanding that his contract did not come into effect until we accepted a USDA RD award.

The Preliminary Engineering Report speculated that the monthly fee ( including construction and debt repayment costs) would be @$80 per month for a single family dwelling, or REU (residential equivalency unit) That figure would be multiplied for larger units such as the schoool or reataurants based on a USDA RD formula,

HOWEVER – the Report also noted several areas where there would be additional costs which could not be estimated – chief among them being additional legal fees, and a ‘buy-in’ per month cost to be levied by the Village of Onekama for operating collection and treatment at their facility on our behalf – the figure stated by them was $21.67 per month in addition to the proposed $80.

It should also be noted that the debt repayment cost is for the maximum of 40 years and interest rate was estimated at poverty rate of 4.5% – and that monthly sewer bills would be sent out whether a resident was here for 3 or 12 months.

The Village has consistently requested a full projected Budget be prepared for us to adopt, as is required under the Articles of Incorporation of the BLPAUA.

Act 233 states: 124.293 Authorization to raise or pay money for administrative expenses or other purposes; direct taxing power.

Sec. 13.

The legislative body of each municipality which is a member of the authority is authorized to raise by tax or pay from its general funds, any money required to be paid by the articles of incorporation for administrative expenses or for the purpose of obtaining maps, plans, designs, specifications, and cost estimates of a proposed sewage disposal system, water supply system, or waste management system. The authority shall not have direct taxing power.

Neither of the 2 Townships has adopted such a budget, merely agreeing to pay $6,1000 to the Utility Authority. Under both the General Law Village Act and Uniform Accounting Standards the Village may not amend its operating budget capriciously. As we have not been asked to allocate additional funds none were included as a line item in our FY2002/3 or FY2003/4 Budgets.

Council approved a letter to be sent to Bear Lake Township Clerk and presented to the BLPAUA Board stating our legal position.

The BLPAUA declined to prepare or adopt a full line item budget – deciding instead to merely present a 3 line item request for legal, admin and general engineering costs. Glen and Dendra voted to present this Budget for Council to consider but it was our advice that Council reject it as inadequate.

A request was sent to the Village for a payment of $6,100.00 to cover (in conjunction with an equal payment from the 2 Townships) the outstanding bills, plus Attorney Wilson’s projected services for the coming FY, plus an additional amount to cover projected Engineering costs.

Upon learning that Prein Newhoff and Attorney Wilson had outstanding invoices Council requested copies of all invoices paid by Bear Lake Township toward both the Feasibility Board and the Sewer Board. An itemized listing was given to Council at its October meeting. It should be noted that Bear Lake Township charged a 25 center per sheet copying fee for allowing us access to the bills we were being asked to pay.

It is our contention a 3 line Budget does not meet the test for government accounting standards. In addition the Village net revenue cannot accommodate unlimited additional requests for money for over-extended expenditures of the Utility Authority. We need to know in advance. The UA seems willing to amend their ‘budget’ as and when they need to.

The additional concern is that, as Village residents pay tax to both the general fund of the Village and Township, Village residents are bearing an unfair proportion of the total fees.

We are insisting that proper fiscal controls be put in place to control costs and return responsibility for Authority activities to the Authority Board. It is our belief that if such fiscal controls had been in place the level of unauthorized expenses would have been properly curtailed or at least pre-approved.

October 2003 USDA RD Proposal:

It appears that an official application was sent to USDA RD for consideration, limiting the project to be considered solely to a joint facility with the Village of Onekama – an expansion of the original project which explains why the cost of the project has risen consistently since 2001. There is a substantial increase in the scope of construction, transmission and treatment, and hence legal and admin expenses, which are a fee based on a % of the total.

The characterization that the cost has increased because of delaying tactics by the Village is both erroneous, discourteous and inflammatory.

We have consistently asked that this project be held to accountable standards and that it be accountable to the tax paying public. It should be remembered that Village residents are being asked, in effect to pay 3 times, in Village, Township AND Federal tax dollars.

The terms of the letter from USDA RD were read into the October Minutes of the Council Meeting. Upon realization that the terms were at a higher interest rate than 4.5%, plus that the ratio of loan to grant money would place an unacceptable burden on residents of the Village, Council voted by unanimous motion to respectfully decline the offer as presented.

Council did not intend that to be construed as a total withdrawal from the BLPAUA but merely that the terms and the project as presented, in our considered opinion, were unacceptable to Village residents.

It was also noted, in the correspondence from USDA RD, that they had the same doubts about specific assumptions and generalization made in the Preliminary Engineering Report as we had expressed in May to Prein Newhoff. USDA RD also questioned how the engineering fees had been calculated and expressly stated that the Report as presented had not documented definitive data showing ‘need for the project’.

These matters, plus the receipt of the Environmental Report were discussed at the last Utility Authority meeting.

Specifically it should be noted that within the Environmental Report is a letter questioning the capacity of the soils in the proposed irrigation area to accommodate the volume of liquid without significant drainage to the aquifer and speculates that this may result in contamination of area drinking water wells.

Council may recall we sent the same concerns in a letter following the publication of the Wade Trim Environmental Report for the Village of Onekama’s part of this project earlier this year. We have formally asked for a copy of the results of the hydrology studies being done on the property. It should also be noted that an area of high ground water pollution has been documented to the south east corner of the proposed irrigation field caused by dumping of PCA sludge.

A proposed course of alternate action:

It is appropriate to restate here the fact that it is the Village which has gone out of its way to keep the public informed about this project. We published an information newsletter prior to the first Public hearing; we published the Feasibility Study on our web site; we have also kept the public informed about our questions and concerns of the administration and design of the system; we published the Preliminary Engineering Report in total on our web site where over 800 people have read it.

And now we offer our suggested retooling of this project.

In view of the figures being quoted, the considerable gaps in projected expenses, the repeated advice from USDA RD themselves in their letter that funding MAY only be available in 18 months, in view of a realistic appreciation of the income levels, and publicly voiced opposition, of our residents, (both Township AND village) we offer an alternate path.

Begin by granting the Village’s share of payment of per diem expenses of our Representatives, plus $1000 toward the additional legal fees, while recognizing that we did not approve those fees. = $3.020.00

Mandate that no additional fees shall be incurred while we proceed to further investigation of alternative options.

It needs be restated here WHY we began this research, consideration and planning of how best to protect the groundwater and public health of our community in the first place.

* We are a community with the ‘potential’ for growth.

* Many of our single family homes within the Village are 3 bedroom homes occupied by single older adults or currently have no children present.

* All our homes are within close proximity to our neighbors.

* ALL our streets flow downhill to the Lake. The Lake is our chief cultural, environmental and economic asset.

In the Village our municipal drinking water supply is protected and monitored stringently. HOWEVER, we and our neighbors are dependent on the same underground aquifer – we know from our Wellhead Protection report that within 40 years we will be drinking the water that came into the aquifer today.

We have no accurate documentation of the age and condition of current onsite septic systems and drain fields. We know it is good policy to have a septic tank pumped every 2-3 years but how many residents actually do that?

We know it is a dangerous and bad practice to put man made chemicals into a septic tank and drain field but we all do that every day. When we talk about groundwater contamination from septic tanks and drain field, it is as important to consider chemical pollutants as it is human wastes and gray water.

Human waste degrades naturally, high concentrations of chemicals do not. We have only to remember the devastating consequences of the PCA sludge dumping and other toxic spills in our area to realize the seriousness of ground water contamination. A single failing septic system may seem trivial – but multiply that by how many individual systems we have in the Village. One individual may be a conscientious home or business owner – but is it fair to them if their neighbor is not?

The Village storm water control system is outdated and simply does NOT work. Unfortunately, by reforming the BLPAUA under Public Act 533 we cut off our source of funding for bonding to rebuild or redesign that storm water control system.

In the 3 years we have been on this journey, technology and DEQ regulations have changed. Solutions which may not have seemed viable in 2000 are eminently viable today.

We agree with USDA RD. Apocryphal, anecdotal statements will not do.

We simply have not done enough groundwork to document the need for a full-blown  municipal sewer system, Moreover, to build such a high cost civil engineering project requires far more resources than this community is currently able or willing to devote or envision.

HOWEVER- doing nothing is NOT an option. If the sewer is the ‘Cadillac’ option – what can be done to protect the groundwater and the public health without subjecting ourselves to a debt of $11.5 – $14M for the next 40 years?

We ask Council to consider returning this challenge and responsibility to the individual. Are we, as a community, prepared to police ourselves?

1) Accept that we are all in this together and eliminate the ‘us and them’ finger pointing. The Village has maintained an informed and professional approach to this issue – we should continue that way. A fouled lake is a fouled lake whether you live on its shores or in the Village. An overflowing septic system stinks whether you are a lakefront property owner or live on Maple Street. At the moment the Lake is NOT polluted – what are we, the community as a whole, going to do to prevent that from happening?

2.) Begin preparing a mandatory septic system monitoring program – look for funding to install small data loggers in every septic tank to document which are working and which are not. Run them for a full 4 seasons to get a real life picture of how this community changes in composition throughout the year.

3) Adopt an ordinance to require a mandatory inspection and pumping of septics every 3 years. Include testing to see if the drain field is saturated and needs to be replaced.

4.) During the year of data logging, look for sources of funding to establish a loan/grant program to help people who simply can’t afford to replace their aging septics.

5) Adopt the same regulations covering septic installation as are currently in use elsewhere – which require gradual increase of filtration devices on existing septic systems in direct relationship to how close your property is to the water front or to the water table.

6) Look at the option of installation of small ‘community’ treatment systems, whereby a street or a block of property could use a central collection point, treatments and drain field. This would specifically benefit downtown business development.

7) Explore the option of contracting with a private entity to build, operate and maintain an central treatment facility as a public/private utility – or contract with the Village of Onekama to accept and treat the contents of mandatory emptying of current septic tanks. This is already being done by other small communities such as ours – why not here? Admit we simply don’t have the personnel and sophisticated expertise to ‘hand hold’ a project of this magnitude but also recognize that leaving it to others to make our decisions for us doesn’t always give the result we were anticipating.

8) Form a community ad hoc advisory committee to do GIS mapping of who lives here now and what the actual current and potential volume of usage is. (Which is what we all thought would be the result of the Preliminary Engineering Study.)

10) Consider reforming the BLPAUA under a return to the Urban Cooperative Act and allow all 3 units of government to explore ways to control run off storm water pollution as well as seek funding for sanitary systems and treatment.

11) In short, our proposal is to respect what we have learned, not blast it as an utter waste of effort – but rather look at it as finding out what we CAN’T do – which now gives us an incentive to go back to the drawing board to find a better way, one that our community can live with economically and will sign on to as plain common sense.

We may not be able to afford our ‘Cadillac’ in this year 2003, but in 2008 or 9, who knows what the economic climate may be?

If we can get the job done within the next 3 years by putting in place a perfectly workable protection plan based on inspection, regulation of compliance and making onsite replacement resources available to anyone – isn’t that a more fair and equitable solution?

Isn’t the bottom line to make sure we all follow the same rules and practice plain common sense?

The argument is that one sewer system is better than 300 points of potential contamination, but what if we could take simple steps to ensure that the vast majority of those 300 systems were up to date, in compliance and working properly?

We are suggesting a more practical and pragmatic solution, one that we can put in place today, one that will protect our community without bankrupting us, and one that treats everyone, regardless of personal wealth or property value or location, equally.


Dendra Best.

Glen Moore.

December 12, 2003